The Containment, A Review

Michelle Adams, The Containment: Detroit, the Supreme Court, and the Battle For Racial Justice in the North, (NY: Farrar. Straus and Giroux, 2025), 389 pages

In the prologue to The Containment author Michelle Adams offers some personal background of growing up in the Palmer Park neighborhood of Detroit, enrolling in the Roeper City and Country School in 1967, finishing high school in 1981 and later becoming a civil rights attorney and University of Michigan law professor.

As an attorney Adams wrote an amicus brief on behalf of the National Parent Teachers Association in the 2006 case of Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1. The Seattle case erupted over another dispute from a race-based effort to integrate Schools, much like the one in The Containment back in Detroit in the 1960’s. The new case offered the John Roberts Court the opportunity to strike another blow against race based integration, which it did. No surprise there but she explains it was the failure of Justice Breyer’s dissent to connect overturning Brown v. the Board of Education to Detroit in the 1960’s that motivated her to tell that story.

The book is divided into three parts, each with eight chapters. Part I, entitled the Soul Force, describes the segregated Detroit schools in the 1960’s and narrates the contending arguments and proposals to relieve it. Adams provides names and short biographical sketches of the many people and their arguments for change to help readers sort through the history. Several factions offered proposals to bring black community control while others proposed various plans for integration with the School Board the focus of protest and demands for change.

The Supreme Court ruling in Brown v. Board of Education made government sponsored segregation, defined as de jure segregation, an unconstitutional denial of equal protection, but de facto segregation existed in Detroit given blacks and whites lived in segregated communities and went to segregated schools. The NAACP sponsored a search for the evidence that segregation was intentional as opposed to the benign result of individual choice.

When the Detroit Board of Education voted to approve an integration plan after considerable debate and discussion, widespread opposition blocked its use. Next, an alternative proposal by then state representative Coleman Young was signed into law as Public Act 48 on July 7, 1970. It partitioned Detroit schools into 8 districts with 4 having a black voting majority and 4 having a white voting majority, but it had nothing about integration; it satisfied no one. Part I ends when Detroiters recalled the school board in a vote August 4, 1970.

Part II, entitled the Containment, starts with the case of Bradley v. Milliken, a case challenging Public Act 48. Plaintiff Vera Bradley was a black mother with a son in a Detroit elementary school and Milliken was William Milliken, Michigan Governor. The complaint alleged de jure segregation and that the Board had been deliberately segregating the schools for many years. Adams needs 130 pages to narrate the case through the federal court from an initial August 27, 1970 hearing before Judge Philip Roth to his June 14, 1972 order to carry out a Metropolitan School Plan to be completed by 1973.

The narrative covers a skeptical Judge Roth who denied a motion to restore the Board’s integration plan, which the NAACP appealed to the 6^th Circuit Court. The court’s opinion concluded “State action in any form, whether by statute, act of the executive department of a state or local government . . . will not be permitted to impede, delay, or frustrate proceedings to protect the rights guaranteed to members of all races under the Fourteenth Amendment.” The 6^th circuit remanded the case to Judge Roth and a trial followed.

Adams provides a thorough and detailed discussion of the evidence and proceedings of the trial, including a review of public comments and their newspaper and TV coverage as well as the legal influence of related school integration cases from other cities. One of the many new attorneys to the case explained “Containment” to Judge Roth as “not a fortuitous phenomenon” . . . but . . . “the result of private and public housing discrimination.” Adams commented that “blacks were viewed as contagions to be quarantined and avoided at all costs.”

Trial evidence included detailed maps of black and white Detroiters living separately, restrictive racial covenants enforced by courts, Federal Housing Administration and federal Home Loan Owners Association discriminatory policy, mortgage lending “redlining,” real estate agents and brokerage discriminatory policy and practice. After ten days of trial, defendants admitted Detroit was segregated. The trial went on with testimony of Dr. Robert Green, a professor of educational psychology and then to testimony of parents and their experience in segregated schools that included busing black children through white neighborhoods to segregated black schools.

On September 27, 1971 Judge Roth made his “Ruling on Issue of Segregation” concluding Detroit segregation was the result of intentional practices, that the state of Michigan assisted in operating and maintaining the system in violation of the equal protection clause of the 14^th amendment. Judge Roth did not offer a desegregation plan but instructed the plaintiffs and defendants to discuss and propose desegregation plans. As discussion got underway Governor Milliken announced the state would appeal Judge Roth’s decision in a speech November 3, 1971. Judge Roth’s metropolitan desegregation order did not come until June 14, 1972, but opponents and proponents were already aligned to fight or defend cross district integration the newspapers labeled as “busing.” Part II ends.

The concluding Part III follows the legal steps to the end of the case. As promised Michigan Attorney General Frank Kelley appealed to the 6^th Circuit Court July 13, 1972. In December, the 6^th Circuit upheld Judge Roth.  Michigan then appealed to the entire 15 judges of the 6^th Circuit, known as “en banc” review. The 6^th Circuit affirmed Judge Roth again. Michigan requested a hearing before the Supreme Court, which became the case of Milliken v. Bradley. On July 25, 1974 the Supreme Court overruled Judge Roth’s order and sent the case back to the district court to devise a Detroit only integration plan. Judge Roth had passed away and a new Judge, Robert DeMascio, was charged with developing a Detroit only integration plan in a school district

Adams adds a thorough narrative of the politics connected to the final legal ruling in these Part III chapters. By now school integration efforts are routinely referred to as busing in national news coverage. Adams devotes a chapter to Richard Nixon and his opposition to busing and dislike of the egalitarian views of the Warren Court. There are profiles of Lewis Powell, William Rehnquist, and Warren Burger that Nixon appoints to the Supreme Court. Another chapter narrates the rationalizations the justices employed to overturn metropolitan school desegregation. Justice Powell did an especially good job deceiving himself that his opinion was all about law and not his white, upper class view of the world. Other justuces ignored that state governments are sovereign and can control schools and redraw school boundaries at any time. The Court’s ruling justified segregation and turned suburban borders into immutable barriers black children cannot cross on the way to school, like fences Adams suggests. The Milliken v. Bradley ruling repeats Plessy v. Ferguson with another separate but equal ruling for the 20^th century and beyond.

The final two chapters fast forward to the present to explore consequences from the Milliken v. Bradley and Detroit segregation in 2025. A 12 page epilogue describes the author’s 2019 return to Detroit with some musing and reflections. Editors and authors like to end books on a positive note, but doing so here was a struggle. In the last four pages Adams remarks on the threats of continuing racism in a nation that feels “like two warring tribes” maintaining a “sanitized” education system that evades the truth. Adams mentions January 6 and current racist division like Tucker Carlson and the “great replacement theory” in a country where we must not “forget our boats rise together or they don’t rise at all.”

The Containment has many people and many related court cases that makes the book complex, but it avoids legalese and reads as well thought out history rather than journalism. Adams has a cast of characters’ list and their part at the beginning of the book and it is well documented at the end. Adams avoids mention of the depressing trump, but keeping him out of the story did not help me feel optimistic about the future. No boats rise now in the United States.

 

 

 

Labor Line

October 2026_________________________ 

Labor line has job news and commentary with a one stop short cut for America’s job markets and job related data including the latest data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. 

This month's job and employment summary data are below and this month's inflation data is below that. 

The latest blog entry The Trump Recession Watch

Click here for a review of the Blog author's new book The Fight Over Jobs, 1877-2024 The book is available for $19.99 as a special offer to bloggers from this site Buy the Book

The BLS Establishment Job Report with data released October 2, 2026.

Commentary From This Month’s Establishment Jobs Press Report

WORSE

The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) published its October report for jobs in September. The Household Survey for September shows the adult civilian population increased by 139 thousand. This month’s changes were like last month only smaller with the labor force up by 485 thousand, the employed up 406 thousand, and the unemployed, up 78 thousand. Those not in the labor force declined 346 thousand. The increase in the unemployed was large enough to raise the unemployment rate .1 percent to 4.2 percent. The labor force participation rate increased .2 percent to 61.8 percent, low but better.

The seasonally adjusted total of establishment employment was up 29 thousand for September. The increase was 28 thousand more jobs in the private service sector combined with an increase of 18 thousand jobs from goods production. The total of 46 thousand new jobs in the private sector combined with a(n) decrease of 17 thousand government service jobs accounts for the total change.

Goods production had 18 thousand new jobs but with natural resources down 2 thousand jobs; construction added 11.2 thousand jobs. Specialty trade contractors had a net increase of 4.4 thousand jobs with residential contractors off 7.9 thousand jobs while non-residential contractors added 12.3 thousand jobs. Construction of buildings added another 4.2 thousand jobs. Heavy and civil engineering construction added 2.6 thousand jobs.

Manufacturing had an increase of 9 thousand jobs with 8 thousand more durable goods jobs and a thousand new jobs in non-durable goods production. Among durable goods, machinery manufacturing added 4.5 thousand jobs and transportation equipment added another 3.4 thousand jobs among other small gains and losses. Non-durable goods production did poorly but plastics and rubber manufacturing added 4.6 thousand jobs; other sub sector manufacturing had job losses.

Government service employment was down 17 thousand jobs with all levels of government losing jobs. The federal government dropped a thousand jobs. State government was down 3 thousand jobs while local government was down 13 thousand jobs. State and local government excluding education was down a net of 10.3 thousand jobs: state government up .3 thousand jobs, but local government off 10.6 thousand jobs. State public education was off 2.7 thousand jobs with local government education down as well, dropping 1.8 thousand jobs. Private sector education was off 3.2 thousand jobs for a net education job loss of 7.7 thousand jobs.

Health care took first place among service sectors with a modest 23 thousand jobs. Three of the four health care subsectors added jobs with ambulatory care adding 13.4 thousand jobs; hospitals added another 12 thousand jobs. Nursing and residential care was down 8.7 thousand jobs. Social assistance services added a net of 6.3 thousand jobs with 10.5 thousand of the new jobs in individual and family services offset with a decreasing month for jobs in child care services, down 2.3 thousand jobs. The growth rate for health care was down from last month to 1.15 percent, well below the average of 2.25 percent per month of the last 15 years.

Trade, transportation and utilities added a net 18 thousand jobs with wholesale trade up 5 thousand jobs and retail trade up 5.8 thousand jobs. Transportation had 7.6 thousand jobs but with the couriers and messengers and transportation and storage subsectors posting job losses of 4.8 thousand. Truck and transit services had the new jobs here, up 5.7 thousand, among other smaller gains and losses. Utilities added 500 jobs.

Leisure and hospitality had a modest increase of 9.7 thousand new jobs that follows last month’s big increase. The arts, entertainment and recreation sub sector added just 2.5 thousand jobs, following job losses last month. The amusement, gambling and recreation subsector was down 3.1 thousand of the jobs. Accommodation and food services did poorly as well with accommodations down 3.6 thousand jobs. Restaurants had 10.8 thousand new jobs, but still an off month for restaurant jobs.

Professional and business service jobs went down a net of 9.4 thousand jobs, more than last month. The professional and technical service sub sector was up a net 6.4 thousand jobs; management of companies was off 500 jobs. The third sub sector, administrative and support services including waste management, lost 15.3 thousand jobs.

Among professional and technical services architecture and engineering services added 5.8 thousand jobs while legal services and scientific research and development services each added 2 thousand jobs. Computer systems and design services had another off month dropping 4.4 thousand jobs among other small gains and losses. Administrative support services did poorly with the always volatile employment services dropping 14.3 thousand jobs. while waste management and remediation services had an unusually large gain of 2.3 thousand jobs.

Information services lost 10 thousand jobs, a second month of job losses although a smaller job loss than last month. Computing, data processing and web hosting had 200 more jobs, but the publishing industry had the biggest job losses down 4 thousand jobs where all other information sub sectors lost jobs. Finance and real estate lost 7 thousand jobs in yet another month of job losses. All the finance and insurance subsectors lost jobs, even insurance carriers. Real estate was down as well; only rental and leasing services had more jobs, up 2.7 thousand. The other services category had a net of 5.7 thousand more jobs, down from last month. Repair and maintenance services was down again losing 3.9 thousand jobs. Personal and laundry services was up 200 jobs while there were 9.4 thousand more jobs at non-profit associations.

The economy added just 29 thousand jobs for September. Establishment employment in September was reported as 159.044 million with an annual growth rate of +.22 percent. Again this month, job totals gyrate up and down with health care showing another low job increase, less than a quarter of the jobs it should have, professional and business services doing poorly and information services and finance both with sharp job declines. This month’s job total is 496 thousand above September a year ago and 1.132 million jobs above September two years ago. Both totals are very low.

September Details 

Jobs

Total Non-Farm Establishment Jobs up 29,000 to 159,044,000

Total Private Jobs up 46,000 to 135,717,000

Total Government Employment down 17,000 to 23,327,000 Note 

Civilian Non-Institutional Population up 139 thousand to 275,554,000

Civilian Labor Force up 485 thousand to 170,262,000

Employed up 406 thousand to 163,152,000

Employed Men up 158 thousand to 85,495,000

Employed Women up 248 thousand to 77,657,000

Unemployed up 78 thousand to 7,109,000

Not in the Labor Force down 346 thousand to 105,292,000

Unemployment Rate increased by .1% to 4.2% or 7,109/170,262

Labor Force Participation Rate increased .2 percent to 61.8%, or 170,262/275,554

Summaries by Industry

Non Farm Total +29

The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported Non-Farm employment for establishments increased from August by 29 thousand jobs for a(n) September total of 159.044 million. (Note 1 below) An increase of 29 thousand each month for the next 12 months represents an annual growth rate of .22% The annual growth rate from a year ago beginning September 2025 was +.31%; the average annual growth rate from 5 years ago beginning September 2021 was +1.54%; from 15 years ago beginning September 2011 it was +1.23%. America needs growth around 1.5 percent a year to keep itself employed.

Sector breakdown for 12 Sectors in 000’s of jobs 

1. Natural Resources -2

Natural Resources jobs including logging and mining decreased 2 thousand from August with 607 thousand jobs in September. A decrease of 2 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of -3.94 percent.   Natural resource jobs were up 2 thousand from a year ago. Jobs in 2000 averaged around 603 thousand with little prospect for growth. This is the smallest of 12 major sectors of the economy with .4 percent of establishment jobs.

2. Construction +11

Construction jobs were up 11 thousand from August with 8.364 million jobs in September. An increase of 11 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of +1.58 percent.  Construction jobs are up 109 thousand for the 12 months just ended. The growth rate for the last 15 years is 2.73%. Construction jobs rank 9th among the 12 sectors with 5.3 percent of non-farm employment.

3. Manufacturing +9

Manufacturing jobs were up 9 thousand from August with 12.652 million jobs in September. An increase of 9 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of +.85 percent.  Manufacturing jobs were up for the last 12 months by 40 thousand. The growth rate for the last 15 years is +.49%. Manufacturing ranks 6th among 12 major sectors in the economy with 7.9 percent of establishment jobs.

4. Trade, Transportation & Utility +18

Trade, both wholesale and retail, transportation and utility employment were up 18 thousand jobs from August with 28.778 million jobs in September. An increase of 18 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of +.75 percent. Jobs are up by 53 thousand for last 12 months. Growth rates for the last 15 years are +.93 percent. Jobs in these sectors rank first as the biggest sectors with combined employment of 18.1 percent of total establishment employment.

5. Information Services -10

Information Services employment was down by 10 thousand jobs from August with 2.739 million jobs in September.  (Note 2 below)  A decrease of 10 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of -4.37 percent. Jobs are down by 120 thousand for the last 12 months. Information jobs reached 3.7 million at the end of 2000, but started dropping, reaching 3 million by 2004 but has stayed below 3.0 million for more than a decade. Information Services is a small sector ranking 11th of 12 with 1.8 percent of establishment jobs.

6. Financial Activities -7

Financial Activities employment was down by 7 thousand jobs from August to 9.082 million in September. (Note 3 below) (Note 2 below)  A decrease of 7 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of -.92 percent. Jobs are down by 107 thousand for the last 12 months.  This sector also includes real estate as well as real estate lending. The 15 year growth rate is +1.11 percent. Financial activities rank 8th of 12 with 5.8 percent of establishment jobs.

7. Business and Professional Services -9

Business and Professional Service jobs went down 9 thousand from August to 22.482 million in September. A decrease of 9 thousand each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of -.48 percent. Jobs are down 47 thousand for the last 12 months. Note 4 The annual growth rate for the last 15 years was +1.74 percent. It ranks as 2nd among the 12 sectors now. It was 2nd in 1993, when manufacturing was bigger and third rank now with 14.1 percent of establishment employment. 

8. Education including public and private -8

Education jobs were down 8 thousand jobs from August at 14.853 million in September. A decrease of 8 thousand jobs each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of -.62 percent. These include public and private education. Jobs are down 52 thousand for the last 12 months. (note 5) The 15 year growth rate equals +.67 percent. Education ranks 5th among 12 sectors with 9.4 percent of establishment jobs.

9. Health Care +23

Health care jobs were up 23 thousand from August to 23.959 million in September. An increase of 23 thousand each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of +1.16 percent. Jobs are up 546 thousand for the last 12 months. (note 6)  The health care long term 15-year growth rate has been +2.25 percent lately compared to +1.16 percent for this month’s jobs. Health care ranks 2nd of 12 with 15.0 percent of establishment jobs.

10. Leisure and hospitality +10

Leisure and hospitality jobs were up 10 thousand from August to 16.969 million in September.  (note 7) An increase of 10 thousand each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of +.71 percent. Jobs are down 121 thousand for the last 12 months. More than 80 percent of leisure and hospitality are accommodations and restaurants assuring that most of the new jobs are in restaurants. Leisure and hospitality ranks 4th of 12 with 10.7 percent of establishment jobs. It moved up to 7th from 4th in the pandemic decline.

11. Other +6

Other Service jobs, which include repair, maintenance, personal services and non-profit organizations were up 6 thousand from August to 6.039 million in September. An increase of 6 thousand each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of +1.19 percent. Jobs are up 34 thousand for the last 12 months. (Note 8) Other services had +.77 percent growth for the last 15 years. These sectors rank 10th of 12 with 3.8 percent of total non-farm establishment jobs.

12. Government, excluding education -11

Government service employment went down 11 thousand from August at 12.521 million jobs in September. A decrease of 11 thousand each month for the next 12 months would be an annual growth rate of -1.08 percent. Jobs are down 167 thousand for the last 12 months.  (note 9) Government jobs excluding education tend to increase slowly with a 15 year growth rate of +.39 percent. Government, excluding education, ranks 7th of 12 with 7.9 percent of total non-farm establishment jobs.

Prices and inflation measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for all Urban Consumers was up by a monthly average of 2.9 percent for 2025. 

The CPI September report for the 12 months ending with August shows the 

CPI for All Items was up 3.4% 

CPI for Food and Beverages was up 2.6% 

CPI for Housing was up 3.1% 

CPI for Apparel was up 3.6% 

CPI for Transportation including gasoline was up 6.2% 

CPI for Medical Care was up 1.6% 

CPI for Recreation was up 2.7% 

CPI for Education was up 3.3% 

CPI for Communication was up 1.1% 

Sector Notes__________________________

(1) The total cited above is non-farm establishment employment that counts jobs and not people. If one person has two jobs then two jobs are counted. It excludes agricultural employment and the self employed. Out of a total of people employed agricultural employment typically has about 1.5 percent, the self employed about 6.8 percent, the rest make up wage and salary employment. Jobs and people employed are close to the same, but not identical numbers because jobs are not the same as people employed: some hold two jobs. Remember all these totals are jobs. back

(2) Information Services is part of the new North American Industry Classification System(NAICS). It includes firms or establishments in publishing, motion picture & sound recording, broadcasting, Internet publishing and broadcasting, telecommunications, ISPs, web search portals, data processing, libraries, archives and a few others.back

(3) Financial Activities includes deposit and non-deposit credit firms, most of which are still known as banks, savings and loan and credit unions, but also real estate firms and general and commercial rental and leasing.back

(4) Business and Professional services includes the professional areas such as legal services, architecture, engineering, computing, advertising and supporting services including office services, facilities support, services to buildings, security services, employment agencies and so on.back

(5) Education includes private and public education. Therefore education job totals include public schools and colleges as well as private schools and colleges. back

(6) Health care includes ambulatory care, private hospitals, nursing and residential care, and social services including child care. back

(7) Leisure and hospitality has establishment with arts, entertainment and recreation which has performing arts, spectator sports, gambling, fitness centers and others, which are the leisure part. The hospitality part has accommodations, motels, hotels, RV parks, and full service and fast food restaurants. back

(8) Other is a smorgasbord of repair and maintenance services, especially car repair, personal services and non-profit services of organizations like foundations, social advocacy and civic groups, and business, professional, labor unions, political groups and political parties. back

(9) Government job totals include federal, state, and local government administrative work but without education jobs. back

top

Notes

Jobs are not the same as employment because jobs are counted once but one person could have two jobs adding one to employment but two to jobs. Also the employment numbers include agricultural workers, the self employed, unpaid family workers, household workers and those on unpaid leave. Jobs are establishment jobs and non-other. back

top

The Betrayal - Ira Shapiro

 Ira Shapiro, The Betrayal: How Mitch McConnell and the Senate Republicans Abandoned America, (Lanham, MD: Roman & Littlefield, 2022) ISBN 9781538163979, 241 pages

In the first sentence of his preface author Ira Shapiro declares The Betrayal as “the most catastrophic failure of government in American History.” A brief discussion of constitutional checks and balances reminds readers our Constitution should be able to prevent autocratic takeover of government. There follows a summary listing of failures of government with Mitch McConnell directing the Republicans and the U.S. Senate, along with a reminder that Trump needed McConnell more than McConnell needed Trump.

The book has eleven chapters and a brief epilogue. The first chapter reviews some Senate history from not that long ago when Mike Mansfield managed the Senate and persuaded Republicans and Democrats to respect each other and their constitutional duties. The second chapter reviews the career and work of Mitch McConnell before Trump took office; especially during the Obama administration.

The remainder of the book covers the period from Trump’s 2016 election to the end of 2021. The chapters recount Mitch McConnell managing his political agenda and on multiple occasions managing Trump during Trump’s first term. McConnell worked hard to repeal Obama Care but fell short, his only personal failure. Next, Shapiro narrates the maneuvers that put Neil Gorsuch on the Supreme Court. There follows the story of saving Brett Kavanaugh for another Supreme Court seat.

After the Democrats took charge of the House following the mid-term elections, McConnell announced his return to obstructing Democrats and Congress in any way possible. The House voted to impeach Trump after his attempt to extort political favors from Ukraine officials, which McConnell predictably opposed and defeated. Shapiro narrates McConnell’s strategy for a Senate trial with its foregone conclusion.

By now in early 2020 with the Covid-19 Pandemic under way, Shapiro tells the story of Trump at his “super spreader” worst with McConnell “curiously disengaged” while occasionally maneuvering between common sense and partisan politics as suited his personal agenda. Then RGB dies and McConnell swings into action to get Amy Coney Barrett, a Scalia protégé, onto the Supreme Court before the 2020 election.

Next comes the 2020 presidential election in a chapter entitled appropriately “The Big Lie.” McConnell refused to condemn Trump for this election denial, which he described as “a few legal inquiries.” When McConnell belated realized that Trump’s misconduct had ended his run as majority leader, he finally got angry enough to speak against him and defend the election in a Senate speech Shapiro quotes in its entirety. Unfortunately for McConnell his speech was delivered on the morning of January 6.

Shapiro recounts daily events leading up to the attack and then a concise discussion of the January 6 events. The attack was so violent and so obviously planned by Trump that the House Democratic majority had enough votes to bring another impeachment. The account of the impeachment and trial follows where Shapiro provides the evidence that McConnell could have delivered the Senate votes to convict, but found an excuse to vote in Trump’s favor.

The book winds down considering the prospects for President Joe Biden in a Senate with a 50-50 split that included erratic allies like Joe Manchin and opponents like Mitch McConnell. A foul mouthed and disruptive ex-president, still a profitable topic for media coverage, attacked every Biden effort.

The stories narrated through the book come peppered with the conduct and quoted views of many people. Of course, there is Trump, but other names come up many times such as dithering Susan Collins, the amoral Lindsey Graham, Mitt Romney, Lisa Murkowski, Lamar Alexander, Amy Klobachar, Charles Grassley, Joe Manchin, Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi, Rudy Giuliani. Still the book remains primarily about the political misconduct of Mitch McConnell and his legacy. Shapiro suggests a legacy for McConnell, but given the brevity of his comments he appears more inclined to let McConnell’s record speak for itself.

While the record is clear, Shapiro uses his final pages to remind us McConnell served as majority leader longer than anyone while suggesting a broader and more damaging legacy than what he did to remake the Supreme Court and save Trump from his various follies. While these make up the primary topics of the book, Shapiro mentions McConnell’s work cutting taxes for the rich, deregulating corporate America, and his fight to end Biden Administration efforts to address climate change, an especially unconscionable misconduct for an 80 year old who will not live to bear the consequences of his work. In summary conclusion, “McConnell has ultimately come down on the side of polarization and disunion rather than compromise and reconciliation.” From McConnell’s published memoir, he comments “there is not a page in it that shows concern about the people of Kentucky.”

The book ended without exploring polarization and disunion in more detail or how much McConnell has pursued the corporate agenda like a devoted follower and paid employee. Corporate America promotes and benefits from the racial and ethnic hatreds that divides the electorate. Division turns the working class into warring factions and keeps them in feeble disarray while allowing corporate America to take their wealth by intentionally impoverishing the working class.

The book reads easily as well organized and well documented journalism. There are 30 pages of notes and a four page essay on sources that serves as a bibliography for any interested readers. Betrayal serves as another book on the continuing decline of the United States. Remember the book’s publication date of 2022; well before the second term. Maybe disunion should be replaced by disintegration

 

 

Construction Laborers

 

Construction Laborer

Standard Occupational Classification 47-2061

I happened to be driving in Ohio in a northwesterly direction on Route 250 just coming up on Norwalk when I passed the sign below for a construction company wanting to hire laborers for $34.00 and hour, an amount that translates into an annual salary of $70,720 a year assuming a forty hour week and two weeks’ vacation.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) defines an occupation, construction laborer, as one of its standard occupations in its Standard Occupational Classifications (SOC) Manual. Construction laborer, a.k.a. 47-2061, had nationwide employment of 1,096,780 in 2025, the biggest construction occupation of 61 construction and extraction occupations. The SOC defines it as a job that “perform tasks involving physical labor at the construction site. May operate hand and power tools of all types: air hammers, earth tampers, cement mixers . . . May clean and prepare sites, dig trenches, brace excavations, erect scaffolding, and clean up rubble . . .”

BLS reports an increase of 209,200 employed as construction laborers from 2015 to 2025 but a smaller increase of 162,780 from 2005 to 2025. The median national wage for construction laborers in 2025 was $22.66 an hour, up from $12.22 in 2005 and $15.34 in 2015. The annual inflation rate from 2015 to 2025 was 3.11 percent, but the annual percentage increase in the median wage was 3.97 percent, assuring an increase in buying power.

The Ohio median wage for construction laborers in 2025 was $26.96, up from $15.51 in 2005 and $17.66 in 2015. The annual percentage increase in the median wage was 4.32 percent, well above the 3.11 inflation rate. BLS reports the 90^th percentile wage for construction laborers as $37.54 an hour; 90th percentile wage in Ohio is $38.04 an hour. A $34.00 assures at least 10 percent of the 1,096,780 construction laborers, or 109,678, make more than $34.00 an hour, but nothing assures applicants will get full time work; the annual wage may not be as much as it looks.

The $34.00 an hour wage for a job doing physical labor that requires no formal educational credential of any kind, not even a high school degree, suggests a company hoping to draw applicants from other types of lower paid, part time work. For a construction job doing day long physical labor suggests a job for younger applicants, but BLS reports population growth of those 16 to 34 years old has slowed to a crawl suggesting a need to add to the wage offer to get what they need. The Trump administration shutting down immigration and deporting immigrants confirms another source of the higher wage. For the savvy teen finishing high school it’s an entry level job with a path to a skilled trade.

We the People

 

Jill Lepore, We the People: A History of the United States Constitution, (NY: Liveright Publishing Co., 2025) 581 pages

We the People begins with an introduction establishing America’s 18^th century colonists expected constitutions will be amendable. Toward the end of this 22 page introduction author Lepore explains the “book is a history of American constitutionalism as told through a collection of stories about constitutional change.” It relies on an archive of every significant proposal to amend the U.S. Constitution, assembled as part of a personal project of the author.

The book has four parts with each part subdivided into three, or once four, chapters. Parts follow in chronological order with Part I from 1774 to 1791; Part II 1803-1896; Part III 1905-1959; Part IV 1961-2016. A brief epilogue ends the book.

Part I opens with the First Continental Congress in September 1774 when the colonies sent delegates to draft a constitutional document to replace British colonial government with a system of self-government. Lepore takes readers through state conventions drafting and attempting to ratify their constitutions and then to the drafting of the 1781 Articles of Confederation.  Narrative continues with the arguments writing our U.S. Constitution at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, the difficulties getting it ratified, and the ultimate drafting and adoption of the bill of rights.

Small groups drafted these many constitutions and then made them public hoping to get them ratified, but mostly they got a torrent of criticism and demands to change them. Opposition to slavery was strong and attempts to end it and define the rights of blacks brought lots of arguments, as did the constitutional status of women and Indians. When the delegates that worked through the summer of 1787 finished their work, there were renewed demands for amendments. Since their new constitution included Article V detailing an amendment process, James Madison convinced opponents they could amend after ratification. He succeeded in getting the constitution ratified as originally written by condensing the many proposals into ten amendments put at the end of the constitution as the Bill of Rights.

In 1787 it was not obvious amending the constitution would be as hard as it has turned out to be. In each of the remaining three parts Lepore has pages with lists of proposed amendments made as part of political party platforms. The lists provide topics for narrating the repeating demands for change by formal amendment, for narrating alternative constitutional interpretations and for reviewing Supreme Court rulings on constitutional disputes brought to it.

Part II has a thorough discussion of controversies over citizenship, the 1843 Seneca Falls women’s rights conference, voting rights, the nullification claims of John C. Calhoun and the claims of Chief Justice John Marshall to make the Supreme Court the final arbiter of constitutional disputes. Discussion of many Supreme Court cases and their influence on law and politics begin here with Marbury v. Madison and continues through the narrative where readers meet more justices with new views and new cases, often contesting and reinterpreting disputes.

The narrative considers the legal and constitutional chaos of the Civil War and reconstruction. Members of Congress proposed many amendments as a hope to avert war. One, the Corwin Amendment, would have prohibited amendments to abolish slavery. It would come again in March 1956 as the “Lost Amendment.” There is a thorough discussion of the 13^th, 14^th and 15^th amendments and the effort to define citizenship and guarantee civil rights to all. Lepore considers the controversies over rights to self government for those living in U. S. territories, especially Hawaii and Hawaiians, but also Chinese, Japanese and American Indians.

The Part III period 1905-1959 included the amendments 16 through 19 ratified from 1913 to 1920, where three of the four amendments – income tax, prohibition, and women’s suffrage – came after decades of protest. An amendment to abolish child labor began appearing on party platforms in this era, mostly as a response to the Supreme Court refusal to allow it; it failed. Lepore gives a thorough review of the Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka Supreme Court decision, the protest that followed and demands to repeal it by defiance or amendment.

In the Part IV years 1961-2016 readers meet Indiana Senator Birch Bayh who took over the Subcommittee on Constitutional Amendments in 1963. He convinced the country and the Congress to ratify amendment 24, 25 and 26 and almost succeeded abolishing the electoral college via another amendment. It was an era of well funded interest groups which brought an unprecedented number of Article V applications for constitutional conventions. Lepore explores a variety of amendment proposals for the right to life, school prayer, a balanced budget, busing, campaign finance, Indian rights and the controversies over judicial appointments. There follows another lengthy discussion of women’s rights and the ERA that includes the efforts of Patsy Takemoto Mink, Phyllis Schlafly and Supreme Court nominee Robert Bork, along with a review of gay rights, black rights and calls for significant changes to the constitution.

The last chapter before the epilogue features the life and career of Justice Antonin Scalia during the years he served on the Supreme Court: 1986-2016. Featuring Scalia appears to be a device to narrate the polarizing jurisprudence of a period when constitutional amendments became impossible. Since Scalia left a trail of academic writing and did not hesitate to give speeches, conduct seminars and offer his judicial views in television interviews, his claim our constitution had an original intent to guide jurisprudence free from politics and personal preference generated significant public argument in these years. Lepore narrates these arguments, emphasizing Scalia’s gun rights opinion in D.C. v. Heller, which captures the hypocrisy of it all.

In her brief epilogue Lepore reminds us our founding fathers believed in reason and progress, but mentions “outdated constitutions undermine democratic governance.” Then she questions if there is a point beyond which a constitution cannot be stretched but breaks. Our Constitution feels obsolete, to be charitable. In We the People Lepore makes it feel much worse than obsolete. By covering events from 1774 to the present Lepore establishes the same disputes occur and then recur as unresolved politics from one century to the next: women and minority rights to wit. Powerful interests have repeatedly exploited the undemocratic features of our constitution to block and stall and impose their will without regard to compromise or democracy or public welfare as the many events Lepore narrates here so clearly prove. Legislation is hard enough to pass in our bicameral Congress, but given the Supreme Court expects to nullify laws passed by an elected Congress, disputes that could and should be resolved with legislation become amendment proposals instead: abortion to wit. Since Article V makes amendment difficult to impossible, change comes to a halt while protest continues or returns in a new generation. The book fully captures the rambling, hurtling cycles of anger, frustration and chaos in a perpetually polarized country. In the 21^st century money alone governs America, where our outdated constitution undermines democratic governance.

Woodrow Wilson: The Light Withdrawn

Christopher Cox, Woodrow Wilson: The Light Withdrawn, (NY: Simon & Shuster, 2024), ISBN 978-1-6680-1078-5

This new biography of Woodrow Wilson gets its subtitle from the first line of the John Greenleaf Whittier poem “Ichabod.”

So Fallen! So lost! The light withdrawn

Which once he wore!

The Glory from his gray hairs gone

Forevermore!

Biographies of presidents typically emphasize their time in office and the political events they pursue, but this biography concentrates on racial and gender discrimination during Woodrow Wilson’s life and how he addressed them before and after he became president The book covers 495 pages with the narrative partitioned into four parts. Part I begins with a summary discussion of the early crusade against slavery and women’s suffrage movement before turning to Wilson’s 1856 birth, early life, education, a brief year practicing law, marriage and accepting faculty posts teaching at Bryn Mawr, Wesleyan University, and Princeton University; he accepted the Princeton Board’s offer to be their president in June 1902.

Other Wilson biographies write extensively of his legislative record: the Federal Reserve Act, Clayton Antitrust Act, Federal Trade Commission Act, and progressive income tax, but none of that appears in this Cox biography. Instead, the narrative through the book emphasizes the documented record of Wilson’s personal relations with family and friends and with university scholars and politicians, both his supporters and detractors. Beginning with his academic years he published books of history and politics in 1885, 1889, 1893, 1897, and 1902. Cox scoured these works and Wilson’s other writing, archival letters, relationships, and associations. The narrative returns repeatedly to the published record of his racial views and his decades long opposition to woman’s suffrage.

The chapters of Part I offer a sampling of Woodrow Wilson’s views during Reconstruction and the early Jim Crow south. He predicts the right to vote without regard to race would “make the ‘disintegration of southern society’ and the ‘irretrievable’ alienation of ‘the white men of the South,’ its ‘real leaders.’” In his History of the American People he explained “It is ‘the mere instinct of self-preservation’ that forced ‘the white men of the South’ to do everything within their power to restore white supremacy ‘by means fair or foul.’”  Wilson’s apologizes for the Ku Klux Klan admitting “the Klansmen ‘took the law into their own hands,’ but undertook ‘by intimidation what they were not allowed to attempt by the ballot.’” He concluded the Klan was “really ‘for the mere pleasure of association, for private amusement.’” Cox provides a thorough narrative of his discomfort and unlikely appointment to teach at Bryn Mawr, a women’s college. Bryn Mawr documents an early episode of a long trail of evidence documenting Wilson’s refusal to accept women as equals.

Part II offers a discussion of him as Princeton President, elected Governor of New Jersey and first term as president. His years in politics forced him to take positions and make decisions on race and woman’s suffrage rather than write or ventilate about them. Cox quotes Wilson as telling his gubernatorial campaign manager he was “definitely and irreconcilably opposed to woman suffrage” and that “woman’s place was in the home.” His writing and documented decisions find him opposed to admitting black men to Princeton, opposing unions, opposing immigrants and purging the federal government of black employees while arranging to have the racist film “Birth of a Nation” shown at the White House.

Available evidence permits Cox to give readers an idea of Wilson in his personal life. Hundreds of letters survive to and from his two wives, Ellen Axxon and Edith Galt, and a third relationship with Mary Peck Hulbert. In letters to Ellen, he wrote “Marriage alone was a woman’s ‘essential condition’ for the performance of her ‘proper duties.’” Readers learn Wilson leaves on vacations without Ellen such as one to Bermuda where he meets Mary Peck and starts an indeterminate relationship of eight years documented with 700 letters. We learn of the personal Wilson, a man of “immutable routines,” who enjoys taking afternoon drives and plays golf as part of his daily schedule, finishing 1,200 rounds of golf as president.

Part III, entitled Holding Back the Tide, covers December 1916 to December 1917, a period that energized the Women’s suffrage movement with intensified political pressure to secure national voting rights. Cox covers their campaign thoroughly. Readers meet many women, the groups they organize and the protest marches and demonstrations they conduct. During this period, Wilson reversed his pledge to keep America out of WWI. He prevailed on Congress to declare war to make the world “Safe for Democracy” while simultaneously demanding to silence opposition to American entry into WWI in a well-documented campaign of repression and censorship. During this period the war became an excuse for Wilson to repress and censor woman demonstrating for voting rights. Cox narrates Wilson’s deliberate use of arrest, intimidation and violence to end street protest that included periods of physical abuse in jails and forced feeding of hunger strikers.

Part IV has the remaining years of his second term. By this time women had the right to vote in 13 states, including New York, increasing the political risk to Democratic party opponents of voting. Then Republicans took over the House and Senate in the November 1918 election. When WWI ended November 11, Wilson insisted on going to Paris to negotiate the peace treaty and establish a League of Nations instead of staying home to confront domestic turmoil, especially passing a federal budget, inflation and violent race riots. Cox tells the remaining story of Wilson maneuvering within his administration and his posturing in the House and Senate in the political fight to secure voting rights for woman. Cox gives details of the Congressional debate and final votes in June 1919. Tennessee became the last state to ratify the Susan B. Anthony Amendment that finally became part of the U.S. Constitution August 18, 1920. The narrative ends here, or rather just stops.

Over many years I have read dozens of biographies of Presidents including Woodrow Wilson. None I know of leave out so much of their political record to focus on the man and the ethical principles that drive their decisions and their conduct as this biography. Any illusion that Woodrow Wilson was a confident, accepting and fair-minded gentleman disappears in this Cox biography. The glory from his gray hairs gone. Forevermore!

 

 

Original Sin: President Biden’s Decline, Its Cover-Up, and his Disastrous Choice to Run Again

Jake Tapper, & Alex Thompson, Original Sin: President Biden’s Decline, Its Cover-Up, and his Disastrous Choice to Run Again, (New York: Penguin Press, 2025), ISBN 9798217060672, $32.00 

 I was given a copy of Original Sin and read it wondering what it could tell me of the Biden saga that I did not already know? We know Joe Biden was 82 for the 2024 presidential election and would be 86 at the end of a second term. How much more information did I need since I could see he had aged just looking at him on television and then he accepted a debate with Trump, which ended any doubt about another term given the blank pauses and fumbling speech. In the Author’s Note they tell readers “Our only agenda is to present the disturbing reality of what happened in the White House and the Democratic presidential campaign in 2023-2024, as told to us by approximately two hundred people, including lawmakers and White House and campaign insiders, . . .” 

 The book has 19 chapters and runs 314 pages and I can testify the authors did an impressive job organizing the material from all those interviews and writing a clearly worded narrative. The primary story they tell shows Joe Biden, his wife Jill and his loyal White House advisors unable to face the very real doubts of a second term; there was denial and a loss of objectivity but nothing Joe Biden did could be called a cover up, a term that connotes legal misconduct. Since presidents have to be visible, their family and advisors have no duty to offer any doubts they might have to the public; the public must expect to make up their own mind. 

The authors interviewed Democratic and Republican office holders, party officials, pollsters and other journalists, both necessary and appropriate, but they added related personal and family history to the primary story. I tried to connect the discussion of the Biden family troubles of sons Beau, and Hunter and daughter Ashley, but that discussion always felt tacked onto their stated purpose: “Our only agenda is to present what happened in the White House and the Democratic presidential campaign.” 

 I found it difficult to construe the loss of son Beau to cancer and Hunter’s legal missteps as part of President Biden’s Decline, or his decision to press on for a second term. The discussion of these matters feels especially callus and unnecessary given just the facts the authors provide. They explain “The Plea Deal.” Hunter would plead guilty to evading $200,000 in income taxes and illegal possession of a fire arm. Biden opponents howled their objections and the federal judge in the case, Maryellen Noreika, a Trump appointee, refused to accept the plea deal, dragging out the case further. 

As I recall President Biden promised to allow his appointed Attorney General, Merrick Garland, to go ahead and prosecute Hunters case as part of his general promise to avoid interfering with federal law enforcement, but that was before losing the 2024 election and listening to Trump make repeated threats to him and his family with claims the Biden’s were part of an “organized crime family.” Recognizing the harassment Trump would create for his family he used his pardon power to protect them at the last moments of his term. In doing so, he was defensive and suggested toxic politics had something to do with the outcome of the case and his need to give blanket pardons. For this decision, the author’s make sweeping condemnation; they quote the prosecutor characterizing the pardons as “gratuitous and wrong” and that Merrick Garland was “tremendously disappointed” and that “To many Democrats, this was another ignominious act by a president who repeatedly put the interests of his family ahead of those of this party and country.” These conclusions feel sanctimonious and hypocritical given Trump’s pardons of hundreds of the January 6 felons. To some of us Hunter Biden’s crimes feel trivial compared to assaulting the U.S. Capital and refusing to accept the 2020 election results. 

I struggle to find a purpose for writing the story of Joe Biden’s Decline. A four page conclusion chapter asks “What if a president is unable to discharge their duties but doesn’t recognize that fact?” The authors admit those close to President Biden were always ready “to attest to his ability to make sound decisions if on his own schedule.” There is a suggestion Congress could legally require the president’s physician to certify to Congress the president is fit to serve, but so far in U.S. history only death assures a president will be unfit for office; there is no mention that anyone in Congress has offered such legislation. The authors mention several other questionable presidents, but offer no solution to future presidents and evaluating their qualification for office. 

 If there was a lessen for the future in the Joe Biden case I could not find it in Original Sin. I make note that both authors have worked in corporate media and wonder if they could keep their jobs writing a similar book about Donald Trump? .